I don't watch winky, so his puch defense is a new concept to me...floyds got it on lockdown though and I dont think anyone has the same counter-punching ability. You just don't see people throwing and not getting hit at all like that. Alot of boxers can dodge, but can they retaliate like PBF? I think this video sends a resounding disagreement with winky being better at defense/offense.
interesting you see it that way leverlorange...you are right that winkys style is more of a cover up defence, while floyd can make the guys miss entirely and still be in position to counter.